Southwark Council goes against the wishes of residents
and hasn’t followed proper development procedure.
24 September 2017
Labour-led Southwark Council ignores the will of the people by pushing forward a destructive and disrepectful burial strategy.
Southwark is failing its people:
No Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) despite already having cleared more than two acres of woods (Area Z and Area D1) and plans to clear approximately ten acres more woods in Camberwell Old Cemetery, a Grade 1 SINC. The legal requirement for an Environmental Impact Assessment is any development over 1 acre. Area Z Camberwell Old Cemtery is three acres. Area B Camberwell New Cemetrey is four acres.
No archaeological assessment – despite both cemeteries being heritage sites with the remains of tens of thousands of Londoners from the 1850s onwards, including more than 300 WW1 and WW2 Commonwealth War Graves, as well as memorials, materials or objects of unknown origin being removed. Southwark’s planning application for Area Z Camberwell Old Cemetery promised an archaeologist on site during development works – but did not state why, what they would be investigating or what methods they would be using to investigate and record the site – where is their report?
Embedded religious discrimination – Southwark’s Burial Service excludes 30-50% of residents for whom burial is the only end of life option by faith but cannot be buried over the dead i.e. most Muslim and Jewish residents, some Christian and Catholic residents. A Borough Burial Needs Assessment would have revealed the burial needs of residents and the fact that Southwark’s Burial Service does not cater for many of them
Developing over war graves without Commonwealth War Graves Commission permission or consultation to locate the 131 WW1 and 14 WW2 soldiers known to be buried somewhere in Camberwell Old Cemetery (as stated on the war memorial). Easily located – but not by Southwark Coucnil, pleading ignorance of their location which is recorded on the public CWGC database.
No consultation of families – over ten years developing a ‘reuse and reclamation’ based Burial Service, digging up or mounding over tens of thousands of graves across both cemeteries. Home Office guidance of the 2007 Act said the law required a test case – and including families must be consulted.
No financial disclosure or transparency of costs, no cost benefit analysis or exploration of alternatives – Burial is available now for all faiths at Kemnal Park, Sidcup, where many Muslim residents already have to go to be buried. This is a valid alternative as evidenced by Diocese of Southwark. They erected a Memorial to the Unknown Southwark Parishioner in 2013 to accompany remains dug up in the Crossrail development.
No Conservation Management Plan (CMP) for either of the two cemeteries – despite being a requirement and which would have included all Commonwealth War Grave locations, the archaeological and heritage assessments and the Environmental Impact Assessments and Woodland Management Plans. CMPs must be agreed with community groups, including us FOCC SSW. A recent apology in an email from Southwark Council for still not having prepared CMPs revealed Southwark is aware of its failure on due process.
Incomplete/insufficient public consultation 2011-2012 on which Southwark has nonetheless since built its ‘story of local support’ to fell acres of woods to mound over or dig up tens of thousands of graves.
In 2011, Southwark threatened to dig up Honor Oak Recreation Ground (within Camberwell New Cemetery grounds) for burial plots. Local people fought of course to save the Rec Ground and in doing so supported other options – presented with little or no detailed information:
- No mention of the need to fell of acres of woods or the removal of the Woodland Level Tree Preservation Order protecting twelve acres of woods in Camberwell Old Cemetery, a Grade 1 Site of Importance for Nature Conservation (SINC) – bats, stag beetles, hedhegogs and more.
- No consultation of all families associated with burials at Camberwell Old and New Cemeteries
- No Borough Burial Needs Assessment to ensure the ‘Reuse and Reclamation’ Burial Strategy would cater fairly for residents, not discriminate against 30-50% of residents seeking burial by faith who cannot be buried over the dead
- No out of borough comparisons with alternatives proposed by community groups for fair burial for all residents without the environmental or ecological damage, for example at Kemnal Park Cemetery where many residents already have to pay privately for burial.